“Empire State of Mind” – Jay-Z with Alicia Keys
(Words/music: Shawn Carter, Al Shux, Alicia Keys, Angela Hunte, and Janet Sewell-Ulepic, available on The Blueprint 3, Roc Nation 2009)
“Empire State of Mind” is overplayed. There are better beats on The Blueprint 3. Jay-Z has a few clever turns of phrase but has sounded sharper. Alicia Keys’ voice has sounded better. The hook borders on trite (“concrete jungle where dreams are made of” and “these lights will inspire you” aren’t exactly poetry). It probably doesn’t need the third verse. Wikipedia tells me that the Sex in the City 2 trailer features it. In short, this is Times Square Jay-Z rather than Brooklyn Jay-Z.
Still, Times Square at the right times still feels magical, and “Empire State of Mind” has that same kind of transcendent magic to it. Whether it’s the way the twinkling piano loop tangles itself with the guitar or the high notes Keys reaches for in the hook, it’s hard to resist such an infectiously catchy track. Jay even changes his flow a little bit in the middle, delivering his rhymes at a quicker, corner-of-the-mouth kind of way, tossing off different New York City images. Even if he’s bragged about his success more skillfully before, the combination of the high life with grittier New York images and memories helps paint the city as a multifaceted world. Ultimately, it works because it’s willing to strive for anthem-like levels. It gives Jay the ability to paint the city with broad, bright strokes, and even if he falls short of the high bar he’s set for himself, it’s impossible to take issue with the song when Alicia Keys starts singing.
More on Jay-Z: Allmusic | Amazon MP3 | Emusic | Last.fm
More on Alicia Keys: Allmusic | Amazon MP3 | Emusic | Last.fm




