[Flash 9 is required to listen to audio.]

“Half Right” – Heatmiser
(Words/music: Elliott Smith, available on Mic City Sons, Caroline Records 1996) 

Until Elliott Smith’s New Moon collection came out a couple years ago, I only knew this version of “Half Right” (or “Not Half Right,” depending on who you consult).  In interviews after Heatmiser broke up, Smith distanced himself from the band’s louder sound, but “Half Right” fits in aesthetically with Smith’s material around the same time period.  Perhaps it’s softer arrangement relegated it to the very end of the album.  In any case, this more restrained arrangement complements Smith’s song without crushing it.  The drums play crisply without getting too heavy (although the bass drum makes its presence known).  When coupled with the bass guitar, the drums give the song depth rather than muscle, making the tune feel fully formed.  Of course, many of Smith’s compositions thrive with just voice and guitar, but “Half Right” benefits from the additional musicians, particularly when the band cuts out before the final verse.  This light dramatic touch, when combined with the haunting harmonies and double-tracking in the second and third verses, gives the song a broader feeling beyond the basic arrangement.  While Smith is better known for his darkly confessional lyrics (and “Half Right” will do little to change that), he became a gifted arranger as well, particularly on his underrated Dreamworks-era albums.  The arrangement in “Half Right” does exactly what it needs to do – specifically, complement the hypnotically beautiful melody in the song without crushing it.

More on Heatmiser: Allmusic | Amazon MP3 | Emusic | Last.fm

TAGGED UNDER: heatmiser | elliott smith | 1996 | 1990s | caroline records |
17 Tumblr Notes

[Flash 9 is required to listen to audio.]

“Jealous Guy” – John Lennon
(Words/music: John Lennon, available on Imagine, Apple Records / EMI 1971)

Like many other great artists, John Lennon took moments that others might call mundane and coaxed out the inner beauty.  While “Jealous Guy” might feel a little over-sentimentalized (mainly because of those syrupy sweet strings in the background), his narrator hits the right emotional notes.  Specifically, the narrator hones in on the insecurity behind jealousy.  No matter how we dress it up, jealousy comes back to this deep-rooted feeling that we aren’t good enough (or, perhaps, that someone else is better).  Rather than fall into a cycle of anger that jealousy often starts, Lennon’s narrator opens himself up to his vulnerability by owning his jealous behavior and admitting to his flaws.  It’s this disarming sweetness that makes him human, and it makes the claim that a hurtful result could come from a place of love a little more believable.  After all, we’re all imperfect, and while good intentions alone won’t yield results, hiding from one’s failings won’t lead to growth either.

Today, six years after Elliott Smith died, I’m thinking not only about his songs but about “Jealous Guy” too.  While many might link the two songwriters together based on their premature deaths, I think of the types of characters both men created.  Both wrote songs about imperfect people who strove to be better, and while many focused on these characters’ flaws and thought of the songs as depressing, it’s an incomplete part of the picture.  Often, both Lennon and Smith balanced the low points with a pervading sweetness and often a sense of hope.  “Jealous Guy,” which Smith playfully covered on several occasions, acknowledges the narrator’s failure yet doesn’t mire itself in pity.  Instead, it’s a plea to remedy the situation and move forward – and hearing Smith’s voice rise as he sings these lines (and laugh as he invites the crowd to whistle along with him) underscores the hope that next time the narrator won’t make the same mistake.

More on John Lennon: Allmusic | Amazon MP3 | Emusic | Last.fm

TAGGED UNDER: john lennon | 1971 | 1970s | Apple Records | elliott smith | cover song - original |
6 Tumblr Notes

[Flash 9 is required to listen to audio.]

“It Ain’t Me, Babe”– Bob Dylan and Joan Baez
(Words/music: Bob Dylan, available on The Bootleg Series, Volume 6: Live 1964: Concert at Philharmonic Hall, Columbia Records 2004)

I don’t know as much about Bob Dylan as I should, and while I could beat myself up about this gap in my knowledge of music, I look at it as a gradual discovery of these songs.  As I go deeper into Dylan’s catalog, I see all of the different aspects of his personality.  Maybe because I started exploring his songs in my early twenties, I’ve always found the young, slightly angry Dylan the most compelling.  Maybe it was borne out of understanding all of the absurd “new Dylan” talk that gets tossed around, but I find Dylan’s more pointed songs the most interesting.  These songs, like “Positively 4ht Street” or “It Ain’t Me, Babe,” find Dylan somewhat resentful of the spotlight.  After a series of brilliant songs full of youthful optimism, Dylan became a “reluctant spokesperson” for his generation.  Later on, we turned this Dylan into an archetype for any young, disaffected artist that reacts to a spotlight like a deer staring into headlights.  Whenever we do this and evoke Dylan’s name with someone like Conor Oberst or Elliott Smith, we usually cut to something like “Blowin’ in the Wind” rather than “It Ain’t Me, Babe.”  Sure, “new Dylan” is shorthand for a singer who is young, socially conscious, at least moderately literate, and has folk leanings, but it usually draws comparisons to the wrong Dylan.  Many of the songs on Bright Eyes’ Fever and Mirrors or Lifted… albums have more in common with the resentment in the post-electric era rather than the rallying cries in Dylan’s Greenwich Village days.

I’m writing about Bob Dylan tonight because it’s the closest I’m coming to a Fathers’ Day post.  My dad never really played a lot of music around the house but a couple times referred to a time where he skipped swimming practice in high school to go see Bob Dylan perform with some friends.  I’ve selected the version of “It Ain’t Me, Babe” from a 1964 bootleg because I’d like to think that would be what he saw that night he skipped out on practice (minus Joan Baez, I’d imagine).  Even if my dad didn’t pass down records from his youth the way others might (and if I ever have children, the way I probably will innately), he’s always been incredibly supportive of my various musical endeavors.  I remember he bought me my first drum set and drove nearly forty minutes away to go buy it.  He always read my music articles and listened to my radio show (when the internet stream was available) even if he rarely knew (or liked, I imagined) and of the bands.  Most importantly, my dad taught me the merits of perseverance.  He would sing the praises of hard work and consistency when he needed to, but he taught these lessons every day by example.  He’s a living, breathing example of someone who aims to be better every day and approaches it in small, manageable doses.  He’s given my brothers and me encouragement to follow our passions, the resources to be successful, and the space to fail.  From a young age, my parents both taught me to follow the path I wanted to follow, and there’s no way I could spend (at this point) nearly six months of my life trying to learn a little more about music and a lot more about being a better writer without either of them.  So I’m sharing a Bob Dylan post today in part because of my dad’s story, but in part because the way that many idolize Dylan is the way that I idolize my father.  Just as there will never be a “new Dylan,” I don’t want to be a clone of my dad.  Instead, my pursuit to be a damn good version of myself is a tribute to the way that he (and my mom) raised me.

More on Bob Dylan: Allmusic | Amazon MP3 | Emusic | Last.fm

TAGGED UNDER: Bob Dylan | 1964 | 1960s | personal reflection | father's day | joan baez | conor oberst | Elliott Smith | columbia records |
3 Tumblr Notes

“Miss Misery (Live-  1998 Academy Awards Ceremony)” – Elliott Smith
(Words/music: Elliott Smith, available on Good Will Hunting OST, Capitol 1997)

Part II: The Academy Awards Performance (Read Part I here)

Even without the Hollywood makeup, “Miss Misery” resonated with audiences, scoring Elliott Smith a deal with Dreamworks (and in the infancy of the internet, being on a major label meant more than it does now) and an Oscar nomination.  Still, the notoriously reserved Smith found himself in an odd pairing during the ceremony – performing between two huge pop ballads – “How Do I Live” from Con Air and Celine Dion’s “My Heart Will Go On” from the Titanic juggernaut. Carl Wilson writes eloquently about this performance in his book Let’s Talk About Love: A Journey to the End of Taste and describes the absurdity of the situation better than I would (in particular the suggestion that Richard Marx would have performed it if Smith declined), so I’ll point you toward his book (a great read) for more of the context of the performance.  In March of 1998, I desperately wanted Elliott Smith to win, if for no other reason than I wanted a song I liked to beat a song I loathed (and if you were a teenage male in 1998, you would have hated that Celine Dion song too- I can now accept that it’s an exceptional piece of pop craftsmanship, but it annoyed the hell out of me then).  Despite having little interest in the rest of the ceremony (that hasn’t changed – I’m writing this while the 2009 ceremony is going), I taped the ceremony in addition to watching it.  I’m a relentless archivist and for the first couple years of my music obsession, I taped as many videos and performances so that I could watch them again (bless Youtube, Hulu, etc – I don’t have that kind of energy these days).  I even went as far as hooking up an old VCR to my parents’ VCR to make a “master tape” (which still exists somewhere, I hope).  

But I digress – I was excited to see Elliott Smith perform this song and wanted to make sure that I didn’t miss it.  So I sat there, watching the ceremony because in order to tape, I had to watch the same channel (bless DVRs).  I remember staying up as late as possible until I inevitably gave up and went to bed.  The next day, I scanned the tape for the performance (which I guess I just missed) and the award presentation (which, of course, went to “My Heart Will Go On”).  I’m almost certain (unless I saw him on 120 Minutes, which was possible, but my memory isn’t clear on this one) that this was the first time I’d seen Elliott Smith perform and I remember thinking how odd he looked standing up there by himself when everyone else had much more elaborate arrangements.  I was at least expecting a band with him or something.  Watching the performance now, I’m struck by a few things.  First, the orchestra’s backing arrangement doesn’t sound as hokey as I thought it might have – it’s actually quite tasteful and similar to his own recorded version (and I love the tin whistle about halfway through).  Also, he didn’t look as immediately nervous as I thought – it’s not until about a minute and a half in that his voice shakes (the “next door” line) – an incredibly human moment in an otherwise surreal event.  It took a lot of guts for Smith to go up there and perform by himself – no other musicians, no dancers or film clips or any other visual to distract the audience.  For the reserved Smith to accept the Sisyphian task of performing before Celine Dion (her performance is cut out of the Youtube clip, but just look at the orchestra before Madonna reads the nominees) and perform in front of the largest audience of his life (and, quite possibly, an audience that eclipsed all his other audiences together) is noble.  In a strange way, Smith’s discomfort (search for any other performances on Youtube and you’ll see he was frequently a captivating and charismatic performer in his own quiet, understated way) goes back to his loyalty to the song.  His choice to uncomfortably protect his song from the overblown Oscar-produced alternative put the song before the singer and created a memorable performance, even if it lives in the iceberg’s shadow.

More on Elliott Smith: Allmusic | Amazon MP3 | Emusic | Last.fm

TAGGED UNDER: Elliott Smith | 1998 | 1990s | good will hunting | personal reflection | oscar performance | celine dion | songs from movies |
5 Tumblr Notes

[Flash 9 is required to listen to audio.]

“Miss Misery” – Elliott Smith
(Words/music: Elliott Smith, available on Good Will Hunting OST, Capitol 1997)

Part I: The Song

Like many others, I came across Elliott Smith through Good Will Hunting.  Both director Gus Van Sant and Smith were from Portland, Oregon and Van Sant used a few of Smith’s songs to help flesh out the film’s misunderstood mind.  These songs share a lot with their creator as well - misunderstood works of precise craftsmanship and the product of a heartbreakingly romantic view of the world.  In 2009, Smith’s suicide defines his legacy to many people (and provides a convenient and limiting critical entryway into his catalog).  This single event unfairly eclipses his gift for songwriting.  Yes, many of these songs have sad undertones, but Smith’s not the first (and certainly not the last) to sing about heartbreak or melancholy, yet many immediately link his songs with dour feelings.

Of course, having your breakthrough song titled “Miss Misery” won’t shake those casual assumptions.  Beneath the protagonist’s message to his former lover, Smith lays out a carefully considered musical arrangement.  Every strummed chord, snare drum strike, and keyboard line serve a specific purpose.  Where others might have erred toward an overblown, theatrical arrangement, Smith’s restraint and efficiency give the song an understated dignity.  In particular, Smith carefully uses vocal harmonies without making them overpowering.  He might not have a choirboy’s voice, but he uses it to the best of his ability, treating it like another instrumental choice.  For example, there’s a moment halfway through each verse where his voice in the background helps ease the transition into the next chord – you’ll have to listen closely for it (for example, when the band first enters) as it sounds almost like a string instrument.  Others might use their moment in the spotlight (as “Miss Misery” was composed for Good Will Hunting, a major studio film – easily Smith’s biggest “break” to that point) as an opportunity to show off one’s abilities, but Smith continued to work the same way he always worked – by making the best choice for the individual songs.

Later tonight - Part II: The Academy Awards Performance

More on Elliott Smith: Allmusic | Amazon MP3 | Emusic | Last.fm

TAGGED UNDER: elliott smith | 1997 | 1990s | track analysis | split post | capitol records | songs from movies |
7 Tumblr Notes

Based on a theme created by: Roy David Farber and Hunson. Powered By: Tumblr | Email SSC
1 of 1
Email Me: Email No spam please.